Minerva McTabby (mctabby) wrote,
Minerva McTabby

Snowflake Challenge: Day 7: favorite trope, cliché, kink, motif, or theme

Fandom Snowflake Challenge banner Day 7: In your own space, share your love for a trope, cliché, kink, motif, or theme... Tell us about it, tell us why you love it, give us some examples and recs. Leave a comment in this post saying you did it.

Time travel, Groundhog Day, serial dimension-hopping AUs... oh, so many!

Do-over stories, done well, make me particularly joyful. When characters die (or fall down some rabbit-hole) and get a chance to go back to some crucial point in life. The Peggy Sue trope.

My earliest encounter with it must have been that movie (Peggy Sue Got Married) or a Star Trek TNG episode called "Tapestry": Q sends Picard back to the age of 21 and gives him a chance to make a different choice. (And I've gone and re-watched that episode just now, for the first time in years. It still rocks.)

Do-over fics: I'm picky and fussy with them - backbutton out if I think they're screwing up the trope (or for the usual spelling/grammar reasons); on the other hand, if the trope's done well, I've been known to keep reading even if the pairing's H/G (here's looking at you, Harry Potter and the Nightmares of Futures Past by S'TarKan).

And what I mean by doing the trope well is wanting more than a simple wish-fulfillment fix-it story.

Foreknowledge shouldn't make everything easy. e.g. Harry gets sent back to 1991 and sorts out every problem in canon within six months. - Making different choices at crucial moments? This should create more problems than it solves, leading to interesting new twists. So the do-over character's foreknowledge becomes less accurate as the timeline changes.

The other annoying thing is when a do-over fic doesn't make enough changes and goes into too much detail. e.g. Harry gets sent back to 1991 and the story plods through all of PS/SS with only superficial differences.

So I've read lots of these fics - including the well-known Back Again, Harry? by Jedi Buttercup (WIP, gen, lovely) and Again and Again by Athey (WIP, LV/HP, needs beta). More in favorites on my FF.net profile.

Memorable do-over in BtVS/AtS: Pandora's Boxer by speakr2customrs (Spike/Buffy, Season 4, outstanding secondary pairing: Riley/Harmony).

Top do-over rec: this, for its great writing and characterization. It made me believe in Snape/Lily (only the second fic to do so, ever; and the first one was in 2001).

Come Once Again and Love Me by laventadorn
Severus wakes up in the afterlife expecting something rather different than being almost-seventeen again. Seriously, what kind of game is this? But wait - Lily's come back, too - from 1981? Perhaps it's a second chance... but to do what?
Rated: M - Drama/Angst - Chapters: 25 - Words: 188,760 - Reviews: 499 - Updated: Jan 27, 2012 - Published: Dec 25, 2011 - Severus S., Lily Evans P. - Complete

Crossposted from McTabby@DW.
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.